The property tax figure on a Lancaster City listing this month comes from two numbers, and both are about to be replaced. One is the assessment, which still uses the county's 2018 base year. The other is the 2026 millage. Lancaster County's reassessment brings in a new 2027 base year, with values that are often double or triple the old ones. City Council's budget vote will set a new rate, and under the mayor's proposal that rate would be less than half of this year's.
Neither number tells you on its own what a house will cost to own next year. Some homes come out ahead and some come out behind.
Three rates on one bill, and the school district carries most of it
A Lancaster City property owner pays three separate real estate taxes. The City of Lancaster's tax FAQ lists the current rates:
| Taxing body | Current rate | Share of the combined rate |
|---|---|---|
| School District of Lancaster | 26.6749 mills for the 2026-27 school year | about 63% |
| City of Lancaster | 12.64 mills for 2026 | about 30% |
| Lancaster County | 3.201 mills for 2026 | about 7% |
One mill is $1 of tax for every $1,000 of assessed value. The shares in the right column are simple division of those three rates. They matter because most of the public argument this fall has been about the city's slice, while the school district's slice is twice as large.
Why the city's rate is expected to fall by roughly half
According to the city's 2027 budget presentation, Lancaster City's total assessed value was about $2.74 billion for 2026. Under the reassessment it rises to $6,052,870,837. That works out to roughly 121% growth across the whole city tax base.
Pennsylvania law doesn't let a city, county or borough keep that windfall. Under 53 Pa.C.S. § 8823, a taxing district's first-year rate after a countywide reassessment generally has to bring in no more total revenue than the year before. A separate, specific vote can push the rate up to 10% above that level. The same section excludes school districts covered by the Taxpayer Relief Act, so this section does not set the school district's rate.
The county has done this before. After the 2018 reassessment, the county's own rate dropped from 3.735 mills to 2.911 so the new values would not produce extra revenue, according to a county assessment notice issued this June.
For 2027, Mayor Jaime Arroyo's proposed budget sets the city rate at 6.069 mills, which the budget describes as a 5% increase "above the revenue neutral rate following the County Reassessment." Dividing 6.069 by 1.05 puts the implied revenue-neutral rate at roughly 5.78 mills. Either figure is less than half of the current 12.64, and the proposal still needs council approval.
The tax base and per-parcel averages
Lancaster County Property Assessment Office director Kevin Edwards told WGAL in June that values were up about 90% on average countywide. "Don't try to apply the current 2026 millage rate to those numbers," he said.
The averages people quote are misleading in their own way. Patrick Hopkins oversaw the city's Department of Administrative Services in 2017, when the city recalculated its rate for the last reassessment, and now consults for the city. He told LNP | LancasterOnline that the per-parcel averages published early on don't show where any one bill is headed. Those averages put the city at 167% and the School District of Lancaster at 153%. Taxing bodies set rates from the total assessed value inside their boundaries.
By that measure, the School District of Lancaster's total assessed value rose about 114% in the preliminary data.
The parcel averages run high because they count every property equally. One rowhome that tripled pulls the average as hard as a shopping mall that rose by a smaller percentage but gained far more in dollars. The total weighs each property by its value, so a large parcel that rose slowly, like the mall in the example below, counts for far more.
A Coral Street townhouse and Park City Mall
LNP's example puts real addresses on this. In the preliminary data, a townhouse on Coral Street in the city's Southwest quadrant went from a $70,000 assessment in 2018 to $227,000, an increase of 223%. The main Park City Mall parcel went from $134 million to $209.5 million, an increase of 56%.
With school revenue held flat, Hopkins estimated the townhouse's school tax would rise about 51%, or about $950. Park City's would fall about 27%.
Running the same townhouse through the city's slice tells the same story. At 12.64 mills on $70,000, its 2026 city tax comes to about $885. At the proposed 6.069 mills on $227,000, it comes to about $1,378. At the implied revenue-neutral rate of roughly 5.78 mills, it would be about $1,312. On those figures, this home's city bill would go up under either rate, because its assessment rose far more than the city's roughly 121% base growth. Most of the increase comes from the reassessment, not the proposed 5%.
The county's own guidance expects about a third of owners to pay less, a third about the same and a third more, depending on "how much the value of your property increases relative to the value of other properties." The Coral Street and Park City figures show how far apart two properties in the same school district can land.
The data Hopkins worked from was preliminary. It does not include changes from assessment appeals or tax relief programs, so individual figures may still move.
The 5% on top is still in play
The mayor's proposal also raises the city earned income tax by 0.1 percentage point. Someone earning $40,000 would pay about $40 more a year, according to the city's acting administrative services director as reported by LNP. The proposal includes no rate increases for water or sewer customers and no fee increases for solid waste, recycling or stormwater.
At a Nov. 2 committee meeting, Finance Committee Chair John Hursh and members Amos Stoltzfus and Marshall Miller said they would vote against any budget that raises property taxes above revenue-neutral, LNP reported. Kat Gastineau signaled she would also oppose the budget as presented. That makes four of seven, enough to defeat it. "I think it's also a mathematical one," Hursh said of his position.
The city's budget schedule set a second hearing for Nov. 17 and a second reading for Dec. 8. On the public budget questions page, former Mayor Arthur Morris asked the city to publish the step-by-step calculation from the current millage to the new rate.
The gap between roughly 5.78 and 6.069 mills on the city's portion is about $29 per $100,000 of new assessed value.
FAQ
When did the reassessment appeal window close? The reassessment appeal window ran 40 days from the June 15 mailing date and closed Aug. 3, 2026. The Lancaster County Assessment Office answers questions at (717) 299-8381.
Does the 10% cap apply to the school district? The revenue-neutral section of state law, 53 Pa.C.S. § 8823, excludes school districts covered by the Taxpayer Relief Act, so that section's cap does not govern them.
Why did the city and school district tax bases grow by different percentages? The School District of Lancaster and the City of Lancaster have different boundaries, so each one's total tax base grew by a different percentage.
If you're weighing a Lancaster City rowhome, The Steve Hammond Team will pull its old and new assessments. We also look for owners in the blocks you want who haven't listed yet. Schedule a free consultation.