At the west end of Mount Joy, a long stone horse trough sits beside West Main Street. It is still filled by the same spring that gave the village its first name in 1813. The building behind it has a new sign. The Lancaster Local reported that Amore Traditional Italian Kitchen & Bar started regular hours on Monday, October 5, after a soft-launch weekend at 905 W. Main St.
A deed recorded in August 1818 described the property as a "Tavern Stand." Since then it has been the Springville Inn, the Florin Inn, The Watering Trough and Amato's Woodfired Pizza. It now belongs to a family whose first pizza shop opened in Mount Joy in 1976. The menu draws on the corner's history directly: one salad is named for Springville, one pasta for Florin and one pizza for Mount Joy.
The village came before the borough
Most of the history comes from the Mount Joy Area Historical Society. Its account begins with the Thomas Bailey plantation, warranted by William Penn in 1739. In 1813, Christian Hertzler bought a large remnant of that land for $32,000. He laid out a village and named it Springville "because of the 'wonderful always flowing spring.'" Hertzler divided the village into 421 lots priced at $110 each. His plan included a cemetery, three squares and a meeting house.
The tavern shows up in the record five years later. A mortgage recorded in August 1818 covered the sale of the property to Arthur Patterson for a "Tavern Stand and other buildings thereon erected." Patterson was a Rapho Township farmer who rented the stand to others to run. In 1820, Samuel Yetter petitioned the county for a tavern license and called the property the "Old Stand." His petition promised he would "conduct himself with decency and propriety and keep up good order and regularity in his house." The tavern was already called old in 1820, two years after the deed.
The village's name changed more than once. Springville became Spring Garden in 1864. Other Pennsylvania post offices already used that name, so it changed again to Florin in 1879. The Historical Society says nobody knows for certain why Florin was chosen, though one story credits three men who liked that a florin was a gold Dutch coin. Florin joined Mount Joy Borough in 1963 and became the Florin Ward. That is why Amore's address reads Mount Joy and its menu reads Springville and Florin.
The trough is also a World War I memorial
People driving by on West Main see a horse trough. Its history goes further than that. The borough's inventory of historic buildings lists 905 W. Main St. with a construction date of 1818. It notes that the building "existed when Christian Hertzler laid out the village of 'Springville.'" The same entry says no other original troughs have been found in Lancaster County.
The trough is not as old as the tavern. A LancasterOnline history column reported that the 1834 bill of sale for the hotel mentioned "a complete Pump of water near the door" but no trough. The trough does show up in a photo from the early 1900s. It took its current form in 1922, when workers set it on a new concrete base, mounted machine guns at each end and added a tablet listing Mount Joy's World War I servicemen. Pennsylvania's lieutenant governor attended the dedication on Sept. 17, 1922, and the Lemoyne Band played a concert inside the hotel. In The Lancaster Local's report on the opening, Amore calls the trough "a rare survivor from Lancaster County's early tavern era." It is also one of the town's war memorials.
Two centuries of names on one sign
The Historical Society lists the Springville Inn, the Florin Inn and The Watering Trough among the building's names, "just to name a few." The same LancasterOnline column filled in more recent years. An owner who bought the hotel in 1990 changed its name from Funzie's Roadside Cafe back to the Watering Trough. In 2000 he added a modern building between the hotel and the trough for private parties and events.
The Amato brothers, Sal, Dario and Tony, ran the building next. LancasterOnline reported that they bought The Watering Trough Sports Bar, Lounge & Night Club and reopened a street-facing dining room that had once held a seafood bar and had been closed off. They added pizzas and Italian subs to the menu. Under the Amatos the building became Amato's Woodfired Pizza and Italian Restaurant, the name the Historical Society page still carries.
The deeds recorded in late May 2026 show the most recent change. ASD Brothers Realty LLC and Salvatore, Dario and Antonio Amato sold 905 W. Main St. to BF Conigliaro Investments LLC for $675,000, according to LancasterOnline's deed listings published June 8, 2026. Four months later, Amore was open. One detail carried over from the Amato years. The building's wood-fired pizza oven stayed, and The Lancaster Local quoted Amore's announcement calling it "Refreshed, restored, and ready to fire up."
A Mount Joy family comes back to West Main
LancasterOnline's opening story reports that the Conigliaro family runs Amore. Their local restaurant history goes back to 1976, when the family opened the original Two Cousins Pizza in Mount Joy. Today there are Two Cousins locations around Lancaster County, and the family also owns Nonna Rosa Traditional Italian Kitchen in Akron, which opened in 2019. LancasterOnline's history of Two Cousins says the first shop was opened by Guiseppe "Joe" Conigliaro "in Mount Joy in 1976 with his cousin, Carlo." A Two Cousins still operates at 37 W. Main St., farther east on the same street.
The About page on Amore's website tells the family story in its own words. It mentions a 1985 fire that "temporarily changed our story," which it says was started by accident by a curious 3-year-old who grew up to own Amore. The section about the new restaurant is titled "Coming Home," and the page says the family is "thrilled to come home to where it all started." The family's Mount Joy story starts in 1976, and the building's starts in 1818.
What's on the menu, and what it's named for
Amore's kitchen focuses on house-made pasta and wood-fired dishes, according to The Lancaster Local. LancasterOnline lists carbonara, Bolognese, Alfredo and lasagna on the pasta side, plus wood-fired pizzas, cocktails, wine and desserts.
The October 2026 menu posted on Amore's website names three dishes after three of the names this corner has carried. The Springville Salad is $11.99, the Mount Joy wood-fired pizza is $17.99 and the Florin Pasta is $29.99. For a table that wants to share starters, the same menu lists Tavola antipasti at $18.99, calamari fritti at $15.99 and steamed mussels at $24 for a full order or $13 for a half. These prices come from the October 2026 menu and may change, so check the current menu before you go.
According to LancasterOnline's opening report, Amore is open from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Wednesday through Monday and closed Tuesdays. Thanksgiving is next Thursday, and holiday weeks can change a kitchen's schedule. If you're planning a meal there with guests in town for the holiday, look up Amore's current hours before you drive over.
Before you sit down
Take a minute at the trough before you head inside. Hertzler's spring still fills it, as the Historical Society describes. The 1922 base is the same one dedicated with the lieutenant governor in attendance. It is an easy stop to show out-of-town guests on the way in to dinner. Our Mount Joy neighborhood page has more on the rest of the borough, and our post on what fills Mount Joy's August calendar covers the town's year-round rhythm.
The borough's historic inventory also lists a farmhouse at 975-977 W. Main St., just west of Amore. That is the farm where Springville was laid out, and the inventory dates the house to between 1700 and 1755. Together, the farmhouse and the tavern mark where the village of Springville began.
If you'd like to live near this end of Mount Joy, The Steve Hammond Team works for buyers who have a particular street or kind of house in mind, and that includes contacting owners of homes that fit. Schedule a free consultation and tell us what you're looking for in the Florin Ward.